Science Says So

I am intrigued by something I’ve observed across generations, from people who are so dissimilar I would hesitate to say they have anything in common. It is a very strange attitude about science.

I observe it most often in social media, because … well, that’s where I interact with the largest number of people, I suppose. They will post an article about something science has proven: the benefits of writing, the harmful effects of sweeteners, the medical benefits of coffee, etc. They will be victorious! Emphatic! Science has proven it; it’s incontrovertible.

But then science will prove something they don’t like. Perhaps they don’t like that tanning beds cause cancer, or that more and more evidence keeps piling up to support the big bang, or that … I don’t know, take your pick, there’s always something. Then suddenly, science knows nothing. Why, just 50 years ago, butter was going to kill you and you needed to eat margarine! Now they’re saying margarine is bad and butter is good. And 500 years ago, scientists thought the earth was flat! What do “scientists” know?

Never mind that not all branches of science are created equal. Nutritional and medical science, for example, versus earth science. The former has so many variables that, while we can continue building up strong foundations, we will probably never understand everything about each individual body, precisely because each body is individual. While earth scientists have a completely different data set and way of forming hypotheses and theories. Never mind that we have clearly made a net gain in scientific and technological advancement. When I want it to be true, it’s true; when I don’t like it, it’s false.

So which is science—magical guessing games or methodical, proven, reliable?


One thought on “Science Says So

  1. I think people have a tendency to base their supposed identity on their beliefs. So if those beliefs are challenged they feel fear, as if their very selves are threatened. It’s so hard to admit you may not be right if it’s actually a matter of life or death. I think it’s that serious to some people. That’s especially true if it’s something you’ve been taught since childhood. Having an open mind is like risking everything. If people are evolving, and I hope they are, then taking too much pride in an idea seems counterproductive. Truth is more valuable than just being right. I don’t think egos care what truth is, they just care about being the right one and being proud of it. That means someone else has to be wrong. If people can start caring more about truth than superiority then we can really get somewhere!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s